Small lot, hand crafted wines from vineyards throughout Santa Barbara County
Home / Whining About Wine / Whining About Wines . . . Wine Clubs

Whining About Wines . . . Wine Clubs

I read an interesting blog last week chronicling a reader’s dislike of wine clubs in general. We’re not talking your run-of-the-mill ‘Wine of the Month’ type club here (and not that I have anything against that club or others like it in particular).

He was talking about a number of wineries’ individual wine clubs, and his disappointment stemmed from his experiences as follows:

* Many of the clubs seemed to be using the club to sell off wines that do not sell well elsewhere.

* Many of the clubs sell wine to their club members are prices that are somewhat higher than can be found in the retail market.

* Many of the clubs ‘bundle’ their wines, requiring you to purchase a number of different wines in order to get the ones you really want.

I was absolutely blown away to hear this, as my experiences with individual winery wine clubs has generally been quite positive. I’ve never felt ‘taken advantage of’ by receiving ‘second rate’ products AND I’ve always felt that the prices I received were lower than could be found elsewhere. In addition, I found that these clubs are a way to ensure access to difficult-to-find wines as well.

I have experienced this last point, though, and those wineries that have continued to practice this bundling have lost my business, as well as others I know.

I’ve tried to learn from this in putting together my own wine club. Though it’s a bit difficult to organize, I’ve tried to make my club as ‘open’ as possible and allow pretty much any kind of substitution you’d like . . .

For instance, my first shipment in the Spring consisted of 2 bottles of our 2008 rose, 2 bottles of our 2008 The Outlier (Dry Gewurztraminer), and 2 bottles of our 2006 Cuvee Christie. I had a handful of club members who preferred all reds – no problem. I had a few that wanted all whites – no problem again. And I had a number that wanted to order a few extra bottles – no problem (and I covered the freight charges for these customers!).

I’m interested to hear your experiences with wine clubs – both those from individual wineries and those put together by retail stores or other third parties. I’ll be sending out our Fall Club shipment in the next few weeks and want to make sure we ‘do it right’ (-:

Thanks in advance for sharing!


2 responses to “Whining About Wines . . . Wine Clubs”

  1. Dan G says:

    Both wine clubs private and from wineries offer the consumer a “gem” wine which may not be available in their area. As a consumer you may not like all wines from either club but I have found most are priced accordingly and what would vbe available thru a wine store is the same price I can buy online. I think both are good and both meet the customers needs.

  2. Spiltwine says:

    Looks as if you are approaching it correctly by letting the consumer decide…
    On the whole, I would imagine your generosity not being taken advantage of and it looks good to have this sort of open door policy when it comes to wines that people don’t like.
    Myself, would probably never join a wine club…but I do work in the industry and get loads of a wine anyway. In fact maybe I should create a wine club getting rid of all the stuff I have. It would be called “Spiltwine Grab-bag” and you get what you get. Except if you don’t like it, than I’ll send you something else….erhhhmmm sorry brain spurt.
    Good luck with getting more members though!